We use cookies only to enhance your experience on our site. We do not sell any of your personal information. By continuing to browse, you agree to our privacy and cookie policy. More information

With the price of hardware falling, VR equipment has become a more affordable option for doctors

When Deona Duke woke up from a medically-induced coma to begin recovering from burns that covered almost a third of her body, one of her treatments was hurling snowballs at penguins. The 13-year-old was set on fire when a bonfire exploded on her and her friend. To prevent infection, burn victims need their bandages changed and dead skin scraped away. Sometimes, even morphine isn’t enough to make that tolerable.
At the Shriners Hospital for Children in Galveston, Duke’s doctors gave her a virtual reality headset. Slipping it on, she was immersed in “SnowWorld,” an icy landscape where she got to lob snow at snowmen and igloos. The Texas hospital is one of the few trying out virtual reality to relieve pain.
“I’d never heard of it so I was a little surprised,” she said. “When I first tried it, it distracted me from what they were doing so it helped with the pain.”
It’s still a new and experimental approach, but proponents of virtual reality say that it can be an effective treatment for everything from intense pain to Alzheimer’s disease to arachnophobia to depression. And as Facebook Inc., Sony Corp., HTC Corp. and others race to build a dominant VR set, the price of hardware has fallen, making the equipment a more affordable option for hospitals looking for alternatives for pain relief.
The idea is that the worst pain can be alleviated by manipulating the way the human mind works: the more you focus on pain, the worse it feels. Swamp the brain with an overload of sensory inputs—such as with the immersion in a virtual world—and its capacity to process pain, to be conscious of it, goes down.

A patient tries out a VR headset for the first time

A patient tries out a VR headset for the first time Photographer: David Nicholson/Bloomberg
“Pain is our harm alarm and it does a really good job of getting our attention,” said Beth Darnall, a clinical associate professor at Stanford Health Care’s division of pain medicine. She says VR, which Stanford has done some pilot studies on, is a psychological tool, like meditation, that can “calm the nervous system, and that dampens the pain processing.”
In research done at Shriners by psychologists Hunter Hoffman and Walter Meyer, and similar work done by Dave Patterson at Harborview Burn Center in Seattle, patients reported less discomfort. Hoffman examined magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scans of patients’ brains, which showed they actually experienced less pain.
“I was very surprised by it. I didn’t have the expectation of it working.”
At Cedars-Sinai in Los Angeles, Ronald Yarbrough is waiting in a room that overlooks the hospital’s landing pad, hoping to see helicopter bring him a donor heart. He needs a transplant after his artificial one failed and is being kept alive by a machine. He has been trying a Samsung Gear VR headset and specially created software from a startup called AppliedVR. It helped take his mind off the fact that he’s confined to a small hospital room that can feel like a jail cell. When his muscles relaxed, his pain receded, he said.
“I was on a lot of pain medication and I’ve been able to whittle that down because I’m not sitting around thinking about it,” said the 54-year-old former truck driver. He intends to buy a VR headset when he’s discharged. “I was very surprised by it. I didn’t have the expectation of it working. When I got into it, I was amazed.”

Ronald Yarbrough tries out a VR headset at Cedars-Sinai Medical Center in Los Angeles.

Ronald Yarbrough tries out a VR headset at Cedars-Sinai Medical Center in Los Angeles. Photographer: David Nicholson/Bloomberg
Proponents of VR are quick to point out that it could have a big benefit over drugs, which can lead to tolerance over prolonged use and sometimes addiction. But VR’s effectiveness still has to be proven, particularly when trying to combat chronic pain. Does the effect last when the headset comes off?
“We know that relaxation techniques like hypnosis, yoga, and meditation decrease your perception of pain, so VR has a lot of promise, but it’s too early for it to be the standard of care,” said Houman Danesh, director of integrative pain management at Mount Sinai Hospital in New York. “It’s a very young technology.”
There’s a lot more research needed before VR is going to be widely accepted as a pain relief method. Brennan Spiegel, a gastroenterologist at Cedars-Sinai who’s also director of health services research at the Los Angeles hospital, is about to begin a study on many more patients. So far he’s experienced a range of reactions. Older patients tend to be less open to it than younger ones. One terminal patient refused to even consider it. One woman, who suffered abdominal pain, got such immediate relief that she went home and bought herself a headset.
The price of a headset and software is tiny compared to the expense of keeping a patient in the hospital for an extra day.
“As a scientist, I want to understand rigorously how something like virtual reality can truly improve health outcomes compared to a control population,” said Spiegel who said he’s seen some amazing results in the 150 or so patients he’s tried it on. “Virtual reality undoubtedly has an effect on the human mind.”

Dr. Brennan M. Spiegel observes a patient using a VR headset

Dr. Brennan M. Spiegel observes a patient using a VR headset Photographer: David Nicholson/Bloomberg
VR’s potential for use in pain management was discovered by accident. Tom Furness is a professor of industrial engineering at the University of Washington and considered to be the godfather of VR by his peers. He started looking into VR 50 years ago when he was in the Air Force, and has spun off more than 20 research projects into companies. One of them was a 1993 consumer headset that relied on a TV tuner and video tapes that sold for $799. It was a commercial flop because of the limited content, but a lot of dentists bought it.
“The dentists loved it because their patients weren’t complaining,” he said. The experience distracted children from their fear of injections, drilling and fillings.
That aha moment led to more research into the long-known phenomena of distraction and meditation as techniques to relieve pain. But just like Furness’ attempt to bring VR to the masses, it was held up by costs. Early VR equipment for medical use cost as much as $35,000 for a headset, said Hunter Hoffman, who studied with Furness at the University of Washington.
That’s all set to change this year. VR is graduating from geeky sideshow to big business and equipment prices are dropping. Oculus Rift Headset retails at $599. HTC’s Vive costs $799. To get them to work, you’ll need a PC that costs about $999 to run the software. The market’s going to continue to expand as Sony adds the capability to their game consoles and smartphone makers upgrade their technology to get closer to the kind of performance needed to provide an effective VR experience.

The economics may make VR an attractive experiment for some hospitals. Hospital care takes up to about 30 percent of the U.S.’s annual $3 trillion in health-care spending, making it the most costly category of treatment. The price of a headset and software is tiny compared to the expense of keeping a patient in the hospital for an extra day. So if there’s a chance that VR could lead to an early discharge, it may make sense for a hospital to spend on the hardware, said Cedars-Sinai’s Spiegel.
Companies such as AppliedVR are already trying to make the distribution and development of the technology into a business. They’re supplying hospitals with the headsets and therapeutic software. Another startup, DeepStream VR, is also working on software and systems that help patients with burns and other injuries. Its ‘Cool!’ software features the adventures of an otter.
They may have some work to do to keep patients interested. The VR made her feel better, but Duke quickly got bored with SnowWorld, and that diminished the painkilling effect.
“For teenagers they should find, like, different games,” she said. “That game they were showing me seemed like it was for little kids.”

Other articles in the category "Health"

October 14, 2020
Professional training and COVID-19: post-summer vacation check-in

How COVID-19 Has Challenged the Professional Training Industry The impact of the COVID-19 crisis on businesses has been immense and, as the summer vacations come to a close, it continues to bring uncertainty into the workplace. Employees, EHS managers and heads of departments ponder the implications of going back to work and possible means of minimizing them. At the heart of the issue, training is also resuming, now driven by a dual challenge. Not only does everyone need to be trained in the new steps and habits they have to practice at work, but training itself should not become an additional source of risk. However, professional training and COVID-19 need not be an oxymoron. On the contrary, the situation might invite one to reflect on the effectiveness of EHS training as we know it and to consider ways in which it could be improved. Professional Training and COVID-19 : Raising Awareness to Make Going Back to Work Safer While many businesses already had strict hygiene requirements in place for their facilities and employees prior to the coronavirus pandemic, the unforeseen event has undeniably changed the situation for most of them. Creating a safe work environment for every staff member now implies respecting a new set of rules (social distancing, wearing a mask, rigorous sanitary measures, etc.). It also means everyone needs to stay informed. Immersive Factory training experts invite every person involved to consider awareness and accessible information as the first and main step towards securing the workplace. Occupational risk prevention can indeed not fulfill its role without perfect knowledge of existing risks, the measures that can be taken to mitigate them and the behaviors recommended in case of emergency (an employee who exhibits symptoms, for instance). Make sure trustworthy sources of information are readily available should any doubt arise. To that end, training is a compelling possibility. For more pressing issues, however, rules can be displayed in full view of anyone it may concern, inviting them to refer to reliable sources of information. The CDC or the NIH , for instance, provide up-to-date advice on the spread of the epidemic and on how to act appropriately. This will allow you to ensure working conditions within your company are as optimal as the situation permits.  Managers with a Responsible, Reassuring Attitude When faced with a situation where various elements of uncertainty, or even risk and danger, throw off a professional routine, maintaining a rational attitude and handling over-solicitation calmly and efficiently is as crucial as it is complicated. Managers and heads of departments need to learn how to redefine their role amid an unprecedented context. According to a survey carried out by Immersive Factory, 77% of them see the number of requests they receive go up, sometimes leading to additional difficulties that should ideally be averted. To avoid such complications, implementing a culture of shared accountability is a good way to prioritize COVID-related issues. Once again, making sure workers have access to reliable information prevents the risk of misinformation which could wreak havoc among them. By providing them with up-to-date knowledge, you can promote a permanent watchfulness which will benefit both the group and the individuals. In keeping with this cohesive approach, communication should be as transparent and as unbiased as possible. Be clear about how the pandemic has impacted your objectives, present a well-thought-out action plan, and explain how the workload is distributed between the employees. This distribution should take their availability into account, all while guaranteeing official recommendations can be observed. Share your reflections on every aspect of the situation and set definite KPIs which will help your team reach satisfactory results. A Positive Environment to Promote Trust and Serenity Making sure measures are enforced does not necessarily mean employees should feel as though they are constantly being monitored as this could give them the impression that management does not trust them. Instead, try to favor communication, openness, and serenity. COVID-19 risk prevention also implies being aware of the psychosocial dangers the unusual situation fosters. Social distancing, wearing a mask, systematic disinfection and other preventive behaviors can create a response ranging from discomfort all the way to very serious consequences affecting long-term mental health . These invisible hazards rarely get all the attention they deserve. Yet, the health crisis has emotional side effects whose impact on businesses should not be ignored. According to a study conducted by Canadian cooperative financial group Desjardins, investing in employee well-being contributes to lowering absenteeism rates and increasing turnover. The survey shows that ROI can reach $1.50 to $3 for every dollar invested by a company. (1) New Work Processes Inspired by EHS Training For many businesses, the best way to follow recommendations to the letter consists in having their employees work off-site, or at least in operating with reduced staff levels. While the benefits of such practices amid a health crisis are easy to demonstrate, the situation is quite different from anything workers are used to. It is therefore important to adopt an appropriate approach. Working from home requires a suitable form of support. Managers need to know how to respond to discouragement, indifference, and sometimes even a feeling of isolation employees can develop from a lack of human interaction. A link between professional training and COVID-19 can be established as a means of countering this difficulty. The interactive tools used to host remote meetings and teleconferences online, for 3D simulation, for gamification and for virtual reality set-ups, for instance, provide a concrete solution to maintain social ties within a team. However, opting for the right approaches is paramount, or they may not have the effect intended. According to the study conducted by Immersive Factory, 80% of businesses gave remote training a try during the confinement period, of which 57% felt it created additional complications. Still, their opinions on how streamlined the managing experience was for these types of training vary. To make remote training and using online tools to interact with one’s peers truly sustainable, quality must be at the heart of the strategies to promote engagement and offer a positive experience. Remote Interactions as a Value-Added Approach to Business Exchanges Instead of seeing remote methods of communication and interaction as an inevitable, last resort solution only acceptable during lockdown, new technologies invite us to rethink business dynamics. Such novel distance learning approaches as immersive learning, for one, meet this particular need. Through gamification, these methods allow participants to experience training ‘as if they were there in person’ without even getting out of the house. Though virtual reality (or VR) headsets used to be a seasoned gamer’s prerogative, serious gaming has now become so popular corporate training seems to favor it over more traditional techniques. Even serious escape games appeal to an increasingly diverse market. And with good reason! From supporting new employees more effectively to streamlining processes involving partners and subcontractors, immersive programs constitute a compelling link between professional training and COVID-19 . For instance, immersive EHS training stimulates learners and promotes memorization. Accessible from anywhere and without requiring any compromises on quality, these solutions rely on highly realistic virtual situations through which participants ‘learn by doing’. Particularly useful in risk management or prevention training, these approaches contribute to reducing the number of accidents. Thus, the Capgemini Research Institute has reported that 83% of the businesses that opted for virtual reality state that they exceeded their objectives in terms of efficiency, productivity and profitability. (2) Whether it be to ensure training can continue without compromising the health and safety of the participants or to teach employees how to observe recommended practices during the pandemic, immersive learning offers excellent results. This explains why more and more businesses wish to find out about its true benefits. Immersive Factory’s study indeed shows that 68% of respondents consider virtual reality a solution well-suited to their sanitary measures. In the future, occupational health and safety will be at the heart of corporate strategies. Businesses will need to tighten their hygiene standards for the long term and to have any staff member who may be sick wear a mask. They will be forced to consider external actors differently and to raise awareness about the issues that pertain to certain work environments. Employee well-being will be given much more attention than ever before. Finally, EHS training will include more and more elements and occupy an increasingly central place in corporate strategies. 90% of those interviewed over the course of our study confirm this tendency. Professional training and COVID-19 are now intertwined to the same extent as other aspects of corporate life the lockdown period had a severe impact on. Presently, as everyone is getting back to work, the lessons learned from the crisis are taking the form of new work habits. If implemented properly, these will contribute to shaping the business world of tomorrow.    (1)  Visa Desjardins (the largest cooperative financial group in Canada), conducted a three-year program to great results. Their objective was to help employees take charge of their own physical and psychological health and to give them all the tools necessary to achieve this goal. These measures contributed to a 28% decrease in absenteeism and to a 54% drop in turnover rates. For every dollar invested by the employer, return on investment was estimated to be between $1.50 and $3. (2) https://www.capgemini.com/fr-fr/news/technologies-immersives-lusage-de-la-realite-augmentee-et-de-la-realite-virtuelle-devrait-simposer-en-entreprise-dici-les-trois-prochaines-annees/    

See more
May 6, 2020
Hygiene instructions for VR headset

Sharing the use of a headset with your colleagues or your family is not without risks, we know that you already take great care to clean your headset between each passage, but it is always good to remember a few simple and effe...

See more
June 19, 2018
Health and Safety in the Workplace: an encouraging report from Assurance Maladie (French Health Insurance provider)

Assurance Maladie’s professional risk department has just published its 2016 report on workplace accidents and illnesses : more than a million cases have been recorded and treated in 2016.Workplace accidents: number of incident...

See more